Industry Trends

The 3 Most Common (and Costly) Mistakes I See When Ordering Custom Labels and Packaging

The 3 Most Common (and Costly) Mistakes I See When Ordering Custom Labels and Packaging

If you're ordering custom labels, stickers, or packaging, you're probably about to waste money. Not on the product itself, but on the easily avoidable mistakes that happen before the order is even placed. I've personally burned through roughly $12,000 in wasted budget on print orders over the years. Now, I maintain a checklist that's prevented my team from repeating those errors for 18 months straight.

Look, I'm not a graphic designer or a logistics wizard. I'm the person who handles the purchase orders. My job is to get what marketing and sales need, on budget and on time. And for seven years, I've watched the same three errors pop up, turning straightforward projects into expensive headaches.

Mistake #1: The "Looks Good on Screen" Assumption

This is the classic. In September 2022, I approved an order for 5,000 custom decals. The artwork looked perfect on my monitor—colors were vibrant, text was clear. The physical samples arrived, and the company logo's specific shade of blue looked… purple. Not a little off. Purple.

We caught it before full production, but it still cost $890 in redo fees and set us back a week. The vendor wasn't at fault. I'd submitted an RGB file for a print job that required CMYK. My screen lied to me.

The fix isn't complicated, but it's non-negotiable: Always, always get a physical proof for color-critical items. Digital proofs are for layout. Color needs to be seen on the actual material, under real light. For a rush job where a physical proof isn't possible? Use a Pantone color code. It's the closest thing to a guarantee.

Real talk: Online printers like 48 Hour Print are fantastic for standard items with quick turnarounds (as fast as same-day for some products). But if your brand color is sacred, you need to build in the time and budget for a physical proof. The certainty is worth more than a lower price with an "estimated" match.

Mistake #2: Ignoring the "Total Cost" of the Order

Here's a surprise: the lowest quoted price is rarely the lowest total cost. I learned this the hard way with a batch of promotional labels.

We needed 2,500 labels. Vendor A quoted $0.12 per label. Vendor B (who we'd used before) quoted $0.15. We went with Vendor A. Seemed like an easy $75 savings.

Never expected the hidden fees. Vendor A had a $50 setup fee ("for custom artwork," which we provided). Their shipping was $45. Vendor B's quote included setup and was $25 for shipping. The "cheaper" vendor actually cost us $25 more. And then the labels arrived with a slight curl at the edges—not enough to reject the whole order, but enough that the application took longer. That's hidden labor cost.

My checklist now has a "Total Cost" box that must be filled: Base price + setup fees + shipping + any potential rush fees. Calculate it for every option. The vendor who's transparent upfront is usually the one with fewer surprises later.

Mistake #3: Vague or Missing Specifications

This one feels basic, but it's where the most expensive fires start. "I need a durable sticker for outdoor use" is not a spec. It's a wish.

I once ordered 1,000 "outdoor durable" stickers for water bottles. They looked great. Then we handed them out at a summer trade show. After a day in the sun and condensation, the ink started to run. A total loss. The material was technically vinyl, but it wasn't laminated or rated for prolonged moisture. My fault. I didn't specify.

The checklist forces specificity:

1. Material & Finish: Don't just say "vinyl." Is it permanent adhesive? Removable? Laminated? Matte or gloss finish?
2. Environment: Outdoor? For how long? Waterproof? UV-resistant? Chemical exposure?
3. Application: Is it going on a curved surface? A textured one? Does it need to be applied by hand or machine?
4. Regulatory Needs: Any compliance text? UL marks? Recycling symbols? Get this right the first time.

A good supplier—like the ones we use at Gorilla for our custom labels and packaging—will ask these questions. If they don't, that's a red flag. They should be guiding you to the right material, not just taking an order.

The 5-Minute Pre-Submit Checklist (That Saved Us $12k+)

This is what we use. It's simple. It takes five minutes. And in the past 18 months, it's flagged 47 potential errors before they became real ones.

Before you hit "submit" on any custom print order, confirm:

✅ File Format: Print-ready PDF with fonts outlined? CMYK for color, Grayscale for black/white?
✅ Proof Type: Physical proof ordered for color-critical items? (If no, Pantone color used?)
✅ Total Cost Calculated: Base price + setup + shipping + rush fees = Final number.
✅ Material Specs: Exact material, adhesive, and finish confirmed for the use case.
✅ Timeline: Production time + shipping time = Delivery date. Buffer added?

That's it. Five boxes. It forces you to slow down for a second and think past the artwork.

When This Advice Doesn't Apply

I can only speak from my experience in mid-size B2B operations with fairly predictable needs. If you're a giant corporation with dedicated procurement teams, you have whole other layers of process. If you're a one-person startup ordering 50 stickers for a craft fair, getting a physical proof might be overkill—your risk is lower.

Also, this gets into very specific legal or regulatory territory (like pharmaceutical or food-grade labeling), which isn't my expertise. For that, you absolutely must consult the appropriate experts and regulations effective as of your order date.

Bottom line: Most of the waste I've seen comes from rushing the step before the order. Taking five minutes to be specific saves days of headaches and thousands of dollars. Every single time.